Great Ideas – But are they good enough?


Dusty Files

A couple of weeks ago I was cleaning out a bunch of computer files. It was supposed to be a ten minute job, unsurprisingly it lasted most of the day.

I found things I had long forgotten, both good and bad, and came to the conclusion if I ever had money to spare one of the first things I’d do is hire an assistant.

Clearly, being organized is not one of my strengths.

Curiously one of the files I came across was a novel that I had written way back in 1992. It was titled, The Cabin. It ran about 75,000 words. Every chapter appeared to its own little story and it seemed to have ended on a cliff hanger. Was part two in the works? I have no idea.


Curious why I called it The Cabin, I ran a search and discovered not one word in the entire novel contained the word cabin. I kind of remember writing it but I have no idea why or where it was going.

I decided to keep it anyway. One of these days I will break it down and try to figure out what in the heck I was trying to do. It’s clear I had an idea at the time, it just didn’t translate all that great into a novel.

Ideas worth keeping

So here’s a question: What makes a great idea and is that idea good enough for full length novel?

I come up with lots of ideas and I’m always writing them down. I’m the guy you see with a notebook and pen in his pocket. I write down everything that pops into my head knowing full well only half will make the cut and some of those that do survive aren’t all great.

But that hasn’t stopped me from trying to create something out of nothing and if you don’t believe me I have a mystery novel titled The Cabin that contains no cabin coming to your town.

A Great Idea

Book 2

One of the lessons I’ve learned in this world of novel writing is to be honest with my self. The ideas may seem exciting but are they good enough for a novel?

Throughout the years I’ve learned to draw my ideas out. Can I see an ending? A middle or a beginning? But most of all does it feel right? Does it contain a dash of magic that pulls me in to their world?

Years ago I wrote a time travel murder mystery. The idea was great. Let’s face it, who doesn’t love time travel with a spic or two of murder and mystery. But not matter how excited I got the story fell flat.

I remember summer came and I rewrote it. Pleased with my newest version I shared it with a handful of people. Sadly it fell flat again. In the end my newest version was nothing more than pumping air into a flat tire.

Most of would have given up that sinking ship and moved on, which is exactly what I did. But a chance meeting with a brilliant high-school kid pulled the ship to shore. Now I can write. Now I can see it where I went wrong.

What do we do?

So where does that leave you and me and our lists of great ideas? Do we file them away and wait for a rainy day, do we pick one and give it a shot or do we hope we bump into a brilliant kid who can steer us away from the rocky shore?

The answer is yes and no. Trust me, I’m still trying to figure it out.

But the one thing I’ve learned in all these years, if an idea will not go away maybe there’s a reason for it. If this idea follows you like a lost puppy in a storm maybe it’s time to put on the breaks and listen. Clearly it’s trying to tell you something.

In the end take your ideas and give them a long look. Including the bad ones. The results may surprise you. Now if you’ll excuse me, I have a Cabin that needs to be inspected.

Cabin 2


7 thoughts on “Great Ideas – But are they good enough?

  1. Great post!!! ’92 I was eight years old!! Maybe check out what films you were watching around that time, I am sure there are a few movies that had cabins used to scare people with. But with Great minds I also had started writing and tossed it a book titled The Cabin. Not in 92 of course but around 2003/4 era lol.


  2. follows you like a lost puppy

    I’ve taken to not writing ideas down. Snippets of dialogue or description, song lyrics, things where precise wording is important, I write down, or sing into my phone.

    But unless an idea is willing to follow me around like a lost puppy it’s not worth my time, as witnessed by my folder full of ideas, none of which I’ve touched while I’ve written the 6 novels I actually wanted to write.


  3. Bryan – I have a Word document that is well over 200 pages long of ideas jotted down (can you jot down ideas if you don’t use a pen?) and paragraphs of items that I want to write about some day if I run out of fresh topics. I have been writing my blog almost six years now and I wonder when I’ll start pulling from this treasure trove? My posts were not so picture heavy in the beginning and now I’m trying to match the narrative to the photos of that day. Once the bad weather gets here, the posts will not be in real time as much unfortunately as it would be more like “The Daily Trudge”..


  4. Those ideas are a treasure. Hang on to them and slowly draw them out. I’m happy to hear you did that but most of all you still have them. So many times we get ideas but we never write them down.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s